PrepTest C2, Section 3, Question 24
Historian: The revolutionary party has been accused of having many overambitious goals and of having caused great suffering. However, most of the party's goals were quickly achieved and the party did not have enough power to cause the suffering the critics claim it caused. So it is clear that the party was not overambitious and caused no suffering.
Historian: The revolutionary party has been accused of having many overambitious goals and of having caused great suffering. However, most of the party's goals were quickly achieved and the party did not have enough power to cause the suffering the critics claim it caused. So it is clear that the party was not overambitious and caused no suffering.
Historian: The revolutionary party has been accused of having many overambitious goals and of having caused great suffering. However, most of the party's goals were quickly achieved and the party did not have enough power to cause the suffering the critics claim it caused. So it is clear that the party was not overambitious and caused no suffering.
Historian: The revolutionary party has been accused of having many overambitious goals and of having caused great suffering. However, most of the party's goals were quickly achieved and the party did not have enough power to cause the suffering the critics claim it caused. So it is clear that the party was not overambitious and caused no suffering.
The reasoning in the historian's argument is flawed because the argument
gives mutually inconsistent responses to the two criticisms
fails to establish that the revolutionary party caused no suffering
fails to establish that any of the revolutionary party's critics underestimated the party's power
provides no evidence that the revolutionary party's goals were not overambitious
fails to consider other major criticisms of the revolutionary party
0 Comments