PrepTest 73, Section 3, Question 4
Psychologist: Some have argued that Freudian psychotherapy is the most effective kind because it is so difficult and time consuming. But surely this does not follow. Similar reasoning�e.g., concluding that a car-repair chain has the most effective technique for repairing cars because the cars it services receive so much work and spend so much time in the shop�would never be accepted.
Psychologist: Some have argued that Freudian psychotherapy is the most effective kind because it is so difficult and time consuming. But surely this does not follow. Similar reasoning�e.g., concluding that a car-repair chain has the most effective technique for repairing cars because the cars it services receive so much work and spend so much time in the shop�would never be accepted.
Psychologist: Some have argued that Freudian psychotherapy is the most effective kind because it is so difficult and time consuming. But surely this does not follow. Similar reasoning�e.g., concluding that a car-repair chain has the most effective technique for repairing cars because the cars it services receive so much work and spend so much time in the shop�would never be accepted.
Psychologist: Some have argued that Freudian psychotherapy is the most effective kind because it is so difficult and time consuming. But surely this does not follow. Similar reasoning�e.g., concluding that a car-repair chain has the most effective technique for repairing cars because the cars it services receive so much work and spend so much time in the shop�would never be accepted.
The reasoning technique employed by the psychologist is that of attempting to undermine an argument by
introducing a principle that contradicts the one on which the argument is based
questioning the truth of its premises
presenting an analogous argument whose conclusion is thought to be obviously false
claiming that the argument is based on a false analogy
suggesting that a supposed cause of a phenomenon is actually an effect of that phenomenon
0 Comments